reflections on sarah's post...
...i have definite pacifist leanings. i'll admit that upfront. i don't know that i am fully committed to the position yet, but i do know that i can't, in good conscience, support the idea of redemptive violence (despite my love affair with mafia movies, vigilante movies, jack bauer, etc).
nonetheless, i found the following experience to be informative, troubling, and thought-provoking. two kids in my after school program were play wrestling while we were outside on the playground yesterday (friday). what started as fourth grade playfulness (between two pretty good buddies) quickly turned in to a real fight with punching and kicking and hurt feelings. it was quickly broken up and i found myself sitting on a bench with both of them on either side of me.
i explained to them how there is no fighting allowed at bird street, that they would be spending a certain amount of time out with me, and that they needed to apologize and promise to keep their hands off each other for the rest of our outside time. "yes, mr. steve," they said. when their time was up and apologies had been offered and accepted i sent them off for the final moments of outside play. immediately one of them (the shorter, stockier one) ran over to the other (taller) kid and punched him right in the gut.
"what are you doing?" i exclaimed. "my dad told me to hit people who picked on me," the kid said. "really," i thought, feeling i might have picked up the hint of a kid trying to pull one over on me.
when his dad came to pick him up we had a good conversation, but the father's bottom line was: "yes, we're teaching him to hit back," and his big line: "he's not going to be any one's punching bag." the dad went on to explain that his son has always been undersized and has been picked on a lot, much of it physically by kids bigger than him. his dad finally had enough and began putting him in self-defense classes and teaching him how to fight back and encouraging him to do so. he also told me that, "in this community you have to be strong...if you show weakness you'll get eaten alive."
hmmm...
what do i do with this? on the one hand i agree with the dad...i don't want this kid to go through school suffering beat down after beat down. i also know what he means about being assertive...what was considered a "life" skill in the world i grew up in is really a "survival" skill here.
but on the other hand i totally disagree with this father. how is teaching a kid fighting skills really going to change anything? the Gandhian quote applies here: "an eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind."
which leads me to the definition of justice...i think a lot of times justice is thought of about in this way: get rid of injustice, get rid of violence, get rid of oppressive situations, etc, or get back at the one oppressing you. it's all about eliminating unjust conditions or simply trying to get some measure of restitution. i think it's more than that...it's not about avoiding bad things, it's about creating opportunities to be good. i hope that for this student, bird street, at least, can be a place where he can be good...where he doesn't have to worry about hitting back or standing up for himself, because, at least in that space, he is safe and respected and taken care of. that is a more compelling vision of justice, in my opinion, than just standing up for oneself or revenge.